Case name
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Big Li Ceiling Pty Ltd & Anor
Known as
Big Li Ceiling Pty Ltd
Commonwealth Courts Portal reference and link

PEG502/2018

Applicant
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner
Date filed
State/Territory
WA
Breach(es) found
Wages and entitlements, Non-compliance with notices
Status
Finalised
Date finalised
Link to liability and penalty judgment

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION v BIG LI CEILING PTY LTD & ANOR

Summary of court decision

On 21 February 2020 the Federal Circuit Court awarded more than $46,000 in penalties and legal costs against West Australian company Big Li Ceiling Pty Ltd and its director Yiting Li.

The ABCC commenced court action against the company in September 2018 following its repeated failure to cooperate in a wages and entitlements investigation.

The Federal Circuit Court found the company failed to comply with two Notices to Produce (NTP) records and documents of its workers and subcontractors during a wages and entitlements audit.

When delivering the judgment Judge Street said:

“The Respondents have deliberately ignored their legal obligation to comply with both the first and second Notices. Their deliberate and flagrant disregard of the NTP’s prevented effective enforcement and investigation of the FW Act.

The Court imposed the following penalties that were 90 percent of the maximum penalty:

  • Big Li Ceiling Pty Ltd pay a civil penalty of $18,900.00 to the Commonwealth within 28 days.
  • Director Yiting Li pay a civil penalty of $3,780.00 to the Commonwealth within 28 days.
  • Both respondents pay the ABCC’s legal costs in the sum of $24,284.72.

The Court delivered its decision after considering the ABCC penalty submissions and noting there was no appearance by either respondent.

Judge Street held:

“The purpose of the NTP’s is to provide the ABCC with an effective means for investigating and enforcing compliance with minimum standards and applicable industrial instruments.

"The Respondents deliberate choice not to comply with the statutory notices undermines their efficacy as an enforcement tool and, consequently, the ABCC’s ability to effectively investigate and enforce compliance with the FW Act.”

Background to the Big Li Ceiling Case

As part of the ABCC’s audit, officers from the agency formally required records relating to the company’s workers on 24 August 2017.

In a statement of claim filed in the Federal Circuit Court in Perth at the time, the ABCC alleged:

  • On 24 August 2017, the ABCC required that Big Li Ceiling provide employee records and documents that included timesheets, attendance records and payslips. The company failed to comply with this requirement.
  • On 26 August 2017, Mr Li contacted the ABCC indicating that he would comply with the requirement from 24 August. The documents and records were not produced by 8 September 2017.
  • On 2 October 2017, the ABCC again required Big Li Ceilings to provide further records and documents including records and documents of subcontractors engaged by Big Li. The company and its director failed to comply with the requirement.

The ABCC alleged the conduct contravened Sections 77(3) of the Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2016 (BCIIP Act).

Penalties
Penalties awarded against Penalties awarded
Big Li Ceiling Company P/L $18,900
Yiting Li

$3,780

Legal costs $24,284.72
Total $46,964.72

 

Related content

Media release - ABCC launches legal action against West Australian ceiling company and its director

Media release - Penalties Imposed on West Australian Ceiling Company and its Director in ABCC Wages Investigation