1. Skip to navigation
  2. Skip to content

Penalties Stick in 'Blue Glue' Matter


VIC , Statement 

Release date: 3 March 2011 

The Federal Court in Melbourne today handed down penalties totalling $110,000 on the CFMEU and four of its officials, and the CEPU and one of its officials.

The penalties were imposed on the union and organisers after the court found that industrial action organised in mid-2008 was unlawful, and arose from Bovis Lend Lease introducing a swipe card system called ‘Blue Glue’ at the:

• ANZ site at Docklands;

• Myer site at Docklands;

• Montage site at Docklands; and

• New Royal Children’s Hospital project at Parkville.

“This matter is another example of unlawful industrial action that was unwarranted. The underlying dispute could have been resolved without industrial action being taken,” said Australian Building and Construction (ABC) Commissioner Leigh Johns.

“The unlawful industrial action included work stoppages, a rally, and a human blockade created to prevent concrete pours from occurring at the ANZ project in the Docklands precinct.

“The delays and costs associated with unlawful industrial action have a broad impact that extends beyond the construction industry, particularly when the action affects, as it did in this matter, the timely completion of the new Royal Children’s Hospital.”

In a statement of agreed facts, the respondents admitted to 14 contraventions of s.38 of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act (2005) (BCII Act) that took place on 23 May 2008, 14 August 2008 and 28 August 2008.

In imposing the $110,000 penalties, the Federal Court endorsed the penalty submission made by the ABCC and the respondents.

 “The agreed, and now Court imposed, penalty appropriately recognises the gravity of the conduct,” Commissioner Johns said.

“The ABCC’s new litigation policy provides that, where possible, we will work with those suspected of contravening the law to avoid extended court proceedings.

“This applies at all stages of the process — including during the determination of penalties — so that all proceedings brought by the Commission meet the highest standards of procedural fairness and public interest.”

EDITOR’S NOTE: The schedule of penalties is attached.

Schedule of Penalties

Date(s)

Conduct or action

Section of BCII Act

Penalty

CFMEU

23 May 2008

By its officers, conducting the vote in relation to which approximately 180 employees attending the Docklands projects failed or refused to perform building work from 1:30 pm onwards.

s 38

$9,500

14 August 2008

By its officers restricting the performance of building work at the ANZ project, obstructing concrete pumps on two occasions, and directing or requesting approximately 11 concreters not to perform a concrete pour at the ANZ project.

s 38

$12,000

28 August 2008

By its officers at the Docklands projects conducting the vote after which approximately 180 employees attending the Docklands projects failed or refused to perform building work from approximately 7:05 am onwards, and directing approximately 200 employees to leave the site.

s 38

$26,750

CEPU

23 May 2008

By its officers conducting the vote and declaring the outcome of the vote after which approximately 180 employees attending the Docklands projects failed or refused to perform building work from 1:30 pm onwards.

s 38

$9,500

28 August 2008

By its officers conducting the vote in relation to which approximately 180 employees attending the Docklands projects failed or refused to perform building work from approximately 7:05 am onwards, and by its officers at the Hospital project directing approximately 200 employees to leave the site.

s 38

$26,750

ELIAS SPERNOVASILIS

23 May 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CFMEU on 23 May 2008.

s 38

$2,500

28 August 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CFMEU on 28 August 2008.

s 38

$2,500

TROY GRAY

23 May 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CEPU on 23 May 2008.

s 38

$2,500

28 August 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CEPU on 28 August 2008.

s 38

$2,500

DEREK CHRISTOPHER

14 August 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CFMEU on 14 August 2008.

s 38

$2,000

28 August 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CFMEU on 28 August 2008.

s 38

$2,500

ADRIAN MCLOUGHLIN

14 August 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CFMEU on 14 August 2008.

s 38

$6,000

28 August 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CFMEU on 28 August 2008.

s 38

$2,500

MATTHEW HUDSON

28 August 2008

Being directly and knowingly concerned in the conduct of the CEPU on

 

    Download

     Print friendly version - 51KB